How to Identify the Cumberland Gap Quarter
A collector's walkthrough for confirming a 2016 Cumberland Gap quarter: the frontiersman reverse, inscriptions, clad edge, mint marks, and look-alikes.
Read the full Cumberland Gap Quarter encyclopedia entry →
Begin with the scenic side, because its inscriptions make the coin unmistakable. You should see a standing frontiersman with a long rifle over his shoulder, facing into a mountain pass, surrounded by the words CUMBERLAND GAP, KENTUCKY, the date 2016, and the motto FIRST DOORWAY TO THE WEST, with E PLURIBUS UNUM. If a quarter shows a rifleman and that exact "First Doorway to the West" phrasing, it is this issue and no other America the Beautiful design.
Confirm the other side is a standard quarter obverse: George Washington facing left with UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, LIBERTY, IN GOD WE TRUST, and QUARTER DOLLAR. All America the Beautiful quarters share this portrait, so the scenic side — not the Washington side — is what identifies the specific park.
Check the physical make-up. This is a copper-nickel clad quarter: about 24.3 mm across and roughly 5.67 g, with a reeded edge. View it edge-on and you should see a coppery middle layer between two paler faces. A coin that is all one silvery color through the edge, or that feels unusually heavy, is likely a silver five-ounce bullion piece or a special strike rather than a normal circulation quarter.
Locate the mint mark on the obverse, just right of Washington's ribbon tie beneath IN GOD WE TRUST. P and D are the circulation mints; S marks San Francisco collector coins. The mint mark affects collector interest but not the identity of the design.
For look-alikes and cautions: do not confuse this with other 2016 quarters (Shawnee, Harpers Ferry, Theodore Roosevelt, Fort Moultrie), which share the same year and Washington obverse but show entirely different scenes and park names. Because these coins are common and inexpensive, elaborate counterfeits are unlikely; the main things to watch for are ordinary wear, cleaning, or post-mint damage. Anything sold as a rare error or a silver version should be weighed and, if valuable, certified by a reputable grading service before you pay a premium.
Frequently asked questions
How do I tell the Cumberland Gap quarter from other 2016 quarters?
Read the scenic side. Only the Cumberland Gap coin names CUMBERLAND GAP and KENTUCKY with the motto FIRST DOORWAY TO THE WEST and shows a frontiersman with a rifle. Other 2016 designs name different parks and show different scenes.
My coin's edge shows copper — is that a problem?
No. That copper stripe is normal for a clad quarter and confirms the standard copper-nickel construction. Only the special silver bullion edition lacks the copper core.
Does the mint mark change what the coin is?
No. P, D, or S all identify the same Cumberland Gap design; the mark only tells you which mint struck it and can matter to collectors. The scenic inscriptions determine the coin's identity.
Should I clean the coin before identifying it?
No. Cleaning scratches the surface and lowers collector value. Identify it as-is from the inscriptions and edge, and leave any valuable-looking or certified-grade example untouched.